Sanibel Island continues to evolve as a top destination in Southwest Florida, with exciting updates to its dining scene. From the arrival of a brand-new pizzeria to the highly anticipated reopening of a beloved steakhouse, these additions highlight the area’s growth, resilience, and lifestyle appeal.
If you're searching for new restaurants on Sanibel Island, here’s what you need to know.
🍕 Scooters Pizza Sanibel Island: A New Must-Try Spot
A fresh addition to the island, Scooters Pizza officially opened on March 2 and is already gaining attention among locals and visitors.
Scooters Pizza introduces Detroit-style pizza on Sanibel Island, known for its thick, airy crust and crispy, caramelized edges. This unique offering sets it apart from traditional options in the area.
Menu Highlights:
- Detroit-style pan pizza
- Hand-tossed pizzas
- Thin-crust 16-inch pies
- 24-inch New York-style pizza
- Boneless chicken wings
- Gluten-free pizza options
With outdoor seating available and strong demand for takeout, Scooters is quickly becoming a go-to for casual dining. The owners also plan to introduce delivery service and gelato, making it even more appealing for both residents and vacationers.
🥩 Courtside Steakhouse Reopening on Sanibel Island
Another major highlight is the reopening of Courtside Steakhouse, located inside the Sanibel Harbour Marriott Resort & Spa.
After sustaining damage during Hurricane Ian, the restaurant has officially reopened with a refreshed concept and elevated dining experience.
Now operating as a dinner-only steakhouse, Courtside features a reimagined menu led by Executive Chef Jennifer Stinson.
What to Expect:
- Nebraska Black Angus beef
- 22-ounce bone-in ribeye
- Fresh seafood, including miso-glazed sea bass
- Upscale steakhouse atmosphere
The reopening was celebrated with a ribbon cutting by the SanCap Chamber, marking an important step in the island’s continued recovery.